One interesting parallel between the two profile pieces from Narrative Journalism is the fact that both writers are present in their pieces, but not too present.
Some pieces (for example, the article that John chose) can be told from a distance, but it seems like others really demand the presence of the writer. I think that "Trina and Trina" is definitely one of the second kind. We see LeBlanc's struggle to help Trina through all the twists and turns of her life. On p. 219, we see LeBlanc's confusion about her dual roles of reporter and friend when she says, "There's no open bed for her to start treatment, but Artie's family needs a break. I exceed my role as reporter, convinced I am going the limit as a reporter, and I take her, fully, in." We also see the way LeBlanc compares herself and Trina, which leads her to draw hasty conclusions. We see the messiness of the situation, and it's not just Trina's messiness. It's the system's messiness, and it's also our messiness.
In "The American Man at Age Ten," Susan Orlean gracefully weaves her presence into her portrait of Colin. She's the one getting hit with the sling shot, and she is also sometimes the one being questioned in stead of the one doing the questioning. I really admired her ability to blend seamlessly into Colin's world and to enter his mind frame. It made it a bit easier for me to jump in myself. At the end of the piece, Orlean is literally trapped in Colin's web. I wondered about this ending - why did she choose it? If I had to guess, I would say it was something about the all-powerful imagination of the 10-year-old...? At any rate, I loved it.
Thinking about the profiles we will write, I wonder: Should we show our presence as an observer/as someone who's processing observations? If so, how can we do this without dominating the piece and making it a personal essay?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The best answers to your questions that I can think of are 1.) yes, I think it's ok to show yourself as the observer in the story, but 2.) don't give personal opinions or feelings about those observations. That's the big difference between Orlean and LeBlanc in these two pieces. Orlean is very much present, but never gives her personal thoughts, while LeBlanc divulges her internal conflict.
ReplyDeleteWell put. I agree with Anna. It's okay to show yourself through a connection to your subject, but strive to remain objective in your reporting. This is where I get stuck.
ReplyDeleteOrlean does a good job of maintaining a professional distance with Colin. Therefore, I find her piece more academically appropriate.
On the other hand, LeBlanc's piece was an excellent read. Although she put herself in the story with explicit instances of internal conflict, I enjoyed reading Trina's story more than i did Orlean's "The American Man at Age Ten."
Where do we draw the line? As a reader LeBlanc's piece was more entertaining and thought provoking. As an academic, Orlean's piece was more responsibly displayed.